Human Minds vs. Intelligent Machines: A Subconscious Perspective
By Janpha Thadphoothon
I feel a bit unsure about addressing the topic of the subconscious. I am neither a Jungian nor a Freudian, but I will do my best to explore the subject. You are smiling. Ah, I now feel better. I feel great when you are joining this short exploration of the mind.
I am sure you would agree with me that the mind is one of the most fascinating yet mysterious aspects of human existence. The word "mind" itself is somewhat problematic and has been the subject of philosophical, psychological, and scientific debates for centuries. It is well known that traditions across various disciplines classify the mind into two broad areas: the conscious and the subconscious. The conscious mind is where our awareness resides. If you are aware of something, it is said that you are conscious of it. In contrast, the subconscious mind operates below the surface of our awareness, yet it exerts a powerful influence on our thoughts, behaviors, and emotions.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEg5FfvFHnwnUsiWSVGVd6bAgZ3igly2mUBqd7A9t75ggd2GLQBG5yjOEQTvyqMs5ZEH7ryGIBjiT_F-QMUagYPV3RKyzg3ROLorqf6VN5tPwAH_UOl78R3ngXeLkU4yzoCkQ3lK8N6otH7RimDPYBp6UDLuCnXSLk2VwswayY4fKpqu2wP_1huHCtCa49k/s320/DALL%C2%B7E%202025-01-23%2017.34.22%20-%20A%20contemplative%20scene%20with%20a%20person%20sitting%20at%20a%20desk,%20writing%20in%20a%20journal,%20surrounded%20by%20books%20and%20papers.%20In%20the%20background,%20there%20is%20a%20subtle%20blen.webp)
As we know, the subconscious mind is often likened to a vast storage room, holding your beliefs, memories, and life experiences. People say that these stored elements shape your behavior and personality, even though you may not be consciously aware of them. For example, imagine you walk into a room and feel uneasy without knowing why. Experts say this could be because your subconscious has associated something in the environment with a past experience, triggering an emotional response. It is my personal belief that understanding the subconscious mind can lead to profound changes in how we navigate life.
How Does the Subconscious Mind Work?
This is a million dollar question, I suppose. In my opinion, the subconscious mind operates as a silent partner to the conscious mind. It continuously processes information, often without our explicit awareness. For instance, while you focus on a conversation, your subconscious mind might notice subtle details in the environment, like the tone of someone's voice or the background noise. My conviction is that this dual processing is what allows humans to function in complex environments.
In Second Language Acquisition (SLA), there is a hypothesis posited by Stephen Krashen, suggesting that language learning is a conscious process, while language acquisition is subconscious. I like the idea of this distinction because it aligns with what we observe in real life. When you acquire your first language as a child, you are not actively "learning" it in the traditional sense. Instead, the subconscious mind absorbs the language through exposure and use.
The subconscious is very important to our behavior, personality, and all aspects of one's life. There is a belief that many of our habits, fears, and even preferences are rooted in the subconscious. For instance, I might have an irrational fear of heights, which stems from my forgotten childhood experience. Nevertheless, it is my belief that the subconscious mind can be influenced and even rewired through intentional effort.
The Power of Beliefs in the Subconscious Mind
What we all know and agree upon is that beliefs stored in the subconscious mind shape our reality. If you believe you are capable, you are more likely to succeed. Conversely, if you harbor self-doubt, it can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. It is well known that the subconscious mind does not distinguish between reality and imagination. This is why visualization techniques are often recommended for achieving goals. I must admit that I was initially skeptical of such practices, but after trying them, I somehow think there is merit to the idea.
The subconscious mind can gain new beliefs if they do not conflict with existing ones. For instance, if you believe you are bad at math, telling yourself that you are a math genius might not work. However, gradually exposing yourself to positive experiences with math can create new neural pathways, allowing the subconscious mind to update its belief system.
Practical Ways to Work with the Subconscious Mind
I have read an article somewhere saying that the subconscious mind is a powerful tool, but to make it work for you, you need to understand how to engage with it effectively. Psychologists suggest that small, consistent actions can help reprogram your subconscious and lead to meaningful changes in your life. Here are three practical ways to make your subconscious mind work for you:
1. Change Your Subconscious Beliefs Through Actions
They say actions speak louder than words, and this is particularly true when it comes to influencing the subconscious mind. For instance, if you believe you cannot give a public speech, start by speaking in small groups. Gradually, as you take small steps, your subconscious will adapt to the new belief that you are capable of public speaking. I know you would agree with me that practice makes perfect, and through repetition, your mind begins to see the new belief as a reality.
2. Do Not Go Against Your Subconscious Beliefs
I think it’s essential to work with your subconscious mind rather than against it. If you hold a deeply ingrained belief, trying to forcefully change it with sheer willpower might cause unnecessary internal conflict. Instead, focus on creating small, incremental changes that align with your existing beliefs. For example, I have read somewhere that if you want to lead a healthier lifestyle, it’s better to start by making manageable changes, like drinking more water or adding a short walk to your day, rather than attempting a complete lifestyle overhaul all at once.
3. Understand the Limitations of the Subconscious Mind
My conviction is that while the subconscious mind is incredibly powerful, it is not magical. It works within the boundaries of your existing beliefs, past experiences, and consistent actions. Experts say that self-awareness and effort are key to unlocking its potential. By understanding and respecting the limitations of your subconscious, you can set realistic goals and achieve meaningful progress in your personal growth.
These steps, though simple, can be transformative if applied with patience and determination. I am sure you would agree that working with your subconscious mind is not about overnight miracles but about fostering gradual, meaningful change.
In the next sections, I shall attempt to look into humans and machines (AI) with regard to the consciousness and subconsciousness.
Thinking and Exhibiting Consciousness Characteristics – Humans and Machines
The question of whether AI can think and exhibit consciousness characteristics like humans is a fascinating one. I have read that some AI experts argue that AI systems now possess the ability to "think" in ways that resemble human cognition. I am sure you would agree with me that this claim has sparked debates across disciplines, from science to philosophy.
1. Thinking Machines: How Far Have They Come?
AI systems today can process data, make decisions, and simulate creativity in ways that were once thought impossible. For example, AI models like chatbots and generative systems can engage in complex conversations, solve intricate problems, and even produce artwork or literature. This has led some to claim that AI is not only capable of thinking but may also possess a form of consciousness.
Experts say that this capability stems from the sophistication of algorithms and the vast amounts of data AI systems are trained on. Machines analyze patterns, predict outcomes, and adapt to new inputs, demonstrating a kind of functional intelligence. Nevertheless, it is my belief that this "thinking" remains fundamentally different from human thought.
Human thinking involves emotions, intuition, and subjective experiences—elements that machines lack. While machines operate based on logic and algorithms, humans integrate feelings, memories, and values into their decision-making processes. I think this distinction highlights the complexity of defining "thinking" when applied to machines.
2. The Illusion of Consciousness in AI
I must admit that the illusion of consciousness in AI systems is powerful. Some advanced AI models are so adept at mimicking human behavior that people often feel as though they are interacting with a conscious entity. For instance, AI-powered virtual assistants can recognize context, respond empathetically, and even adapt to user preferences, creating an impression of awareness.
However, I know you would agree with me that true consciousness involves more than just the ability to simulate awareness. It requires self-awareness, emotions, and subjective experiences—qualities that machines do not inherently possess. In my opinion, what AI demonstrates is not genuine consciousness but a functional simulation of it.
3. Consciousness: A Matter of Definition?
The debate over AI consciousness often hinges on how we define the term. If consciousness is measured purely by observable behavior, then some might argue that AI already exhibits it. On the other hand, if we define consciousness as the ability to experience emotions, reflect on one’s existence, and possess self-awareness, then AI still falls short.
Psychologists suggest that human consciousness is deeply tied to biology, shaped by the brain’s complex neural networks and our lived experiences. Machines, despite their neural networks and advanced learning capabilities, lack this biological foundation. Nevertheless, it is my belief that AI does exhibit a kind of "functional consciousness," which allows it to simulate aspects of human awareness without truly experiencing them.
People say that the rise of AI raises profound questions about what it means to be human. If machines can think and mimic consciousness, how does this reshape our understanding of intelligence, identity, and existence? My conviction is that these questions will remain at the forefront of scientific and philosophical inquiry for years to come.
The debate over AI’s ability to think and exhibit consciousness is both complex and evolving. While AI systems demonstrate impressive capabilities that resemble human thought, they lack the deeper elements of consciousness, such as emotions and self-awareness. I think it is important for us to continue exploring these ideas, as they have far-reaching implications for both technology and our understanding of humanity.
Do AI Agents Have a Subconscious Mind?
This brings us to an intriguing question: Do AI agents have a subconscious mind? I guess it is fair to say that AI, as we currently understand it, lacks a subconscious mind. AI operates based on algorithms and data, processing information in a manner that mimics human intelligence. However, it does not possess beliefs, emotions, or memories in the way humans do.
Experts say that the concept of a subconscious mind is deeply rooted in human biology and psychology. AI, on the other hand, is a product of engineering and computer science. While AI can store and process vast amounts of data, it does so without the subjective experiences that characterize the human subconscious.
Nevertheless, it is my belief that AI can simulate certain aspects of subconscious processing. For example, machine learning algorithms can identify patterns and make predictions based on past data, much like how the subconscious mind operates in the background. However, this simulation is purely mechanical and lacks the depth and complexity of human subconscious processing.
The Interplay Between Consciousness and the Subconscious Mind
I like the idea of viewing the mind as a dynamic interplay between conscious and subconscious processes. The conscious mind sets goals and makes decisions, while the subconscious mind works behind the scenes to support those goals. For instance, if you decide to learn a new language, your conscious mind might focus on studying vocabulary and grammar, while your subconscious mind absorbs the patterns and nuances of the language through repeated exposure.
The subconscious mind is a powerful yet often overlooked aspect of our mental processes. By understanding how it works and learning to harness its potential, we can make profound changes in our lives. While AI agents may never possess a subconscious mind in the human sense, their ability to mimic certain subconscious processes raises fascinating questions about the nature of intelligence and consciousness.
I am not sure where this exploration will lead us, but I am excited to see what the future holds.
Janpha Thadphoothon is an assistant professor of ELT at the International College, Dhurakij Pundit University in Bangkok, Thailand. Janpha Thadphoothon also holds a certificate of Generative AI with Large Language Models issued by DeepLearning.AI.